top of page
AI Jobs Fair Image.png


AI & Data Centers

Governor Josh Shapiro boasts that Pennsylvania is AI Ready. The Better Path Coalition and No False Climate Solutions PA delivered a statement signed by more than 40 organizations and 2,000 individuals that says that he may be AI Ready, but we're not.

People are turning out in the hundreds to municipal meetings when data centers are proposed for their communities. They're saying NO to data centers, and for many good reasons we've summarized below.

Data centers are commonly described as being energy hogs, but that doesn't adequately capture the scale of what is being proposed. Here are just a couple of examples.

The proposed Homer City data center in Indiana County would be powered by a new natural gas power plant that would be the largest in the country. It would provide 4.5GW of power.

PPL Corp. has signed agreements to supply 20.5GW of power to data center customers in Pennsylvania.

1GW of energy powers 750,000 homes. Pennsylvania has 5.8 million homes. That means that the Homer City plant alone would produce enough energy to power nearly 60% of all the homes in the state. And just one company would provide its data center customers with enough energy to power 15,375,000 homes, or nearly three times the number of homes in the state.

The obscene energy demand is just one of the concerns. What possible upside could justify data center development? As is always the case when the state looks to bring a new polluting industry to the state, we're told that data centers will bring jobs to Pennsylvania.

The fact is that data centers create very few permanent jobs. But there's more to the story. Unlike attempted booms of the past, the Artificial Intelligence (AI) at the heart of the data center boom will take away jobs. According to the December 4 Challenger Report that analyses the jobs market, AI is responsible for 54,694 job layoff plans announced so far this year. Since it was first stated as a reason for cuts in 2023, AI has led to 71,683 jobs losses. The pace of job cuts is increasing.

In October, internal documents obtained by The New York Times revealed that Amazon has plans to replace 600,000 jobs with robots by 2027. Governor Shapiro frequently boasts of the deal he struck with Amazon to invest $20 billion to build at least two data centers in Pennsylvania.

See what some executives are saying...

Areas of Concern

Environment Data Centers.png

Environmental Concerns

  • Data centers strain water supplies. A large data center can consume 5 billion gallons a day. That's roughly the same amount of water a small town of 50,000 uses.

  • Noise pollution is a frequent complaint by people who live near data centers. "Chronic exposure causes sleep disturbance, headache, hearing loss, elevated stress hormone levels, hypertension, anxiety, and even cardiovascular risks." Noise also disrupts wildlife, causing alterations to their communication, behavior, and migration patterns.

  • Generative AI may produce as much as 5 million tons of e-waste annually according to a 2024 study.

  • Within the next year, a single 1GW data center may release 350 million gallons of wastewater per year, but " if we scale up power consumption in these data centers by two orders of magnitude at the same WUE (i.e. 100 GW clusters), only 30 of these data centers will release the equivalent of all wastewater released in the US annually."

  • Natural gas will be used to power all but two proposed data centers in Pennsylvania. All of the adverse impacts experienced by those who live and work here over the past two decades will continue.

  • Natural gas production adversely affects the climate, but so does the astronomical amount of energy used by the data centers themselves. Analysis from MIT Technology Review concluded that electricity used in data centers is "48% more carbon-intensive than the U.S. average." 

  • PennState says that it's hard to know how much water data centers use because they're typically not required to report it, among other reasons.

Economics Data Centers.png

Economic Concerns

  • Inside Climate News recently reported that "many Pennsylvanians saw their electricity rates increase between 5 and 12 percent–and some as much as 40 percent–according to the Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission." Virginia, the state hardest hit by data centers, with 666 dotting the state, experienced a 13% increase in electricity prices in the 12 months ending in August. 

  • AI is threatening jobs, as we've noted elsewhere. Among the companies whose executives are quoted above, three of them have operations in PA. According to the PA Department of Labor and Industry, two of them, Walmart (#3) and Amazon (#5) are among the top 10. The third is IBM (#529).

  • Carbon Direct notes that ratepayers will be left holding the bag if data centers become stranded assets. "Once built, ratepayers will have to continue paying for these long-lived investments for years, even if they are underutilized or retired early due to policy shifts."

Ethics Data Centers.png

Ethical Concerns

  • Artificial Intelligence and the data centers that support them are riddled with unknowns that remain unexplored and knowns that are ignored as the public and private sectors race to get their feet in the door of this new industry. This leap-before-you-look carelessness has important ethical implications.

  • Data centers that rely on incomprehensible amounts of fossil fuel-based energy and water will exacerbate the already intensifying climate crisis.

  • Communities whose harms from the adverse impacts of fossil fuel extraction, production, transmission, and distribution have never been addressed will continue to be harmed.

  • Data centers are too frequently placed in regions that are already experiencing water scarcity. The New York Times wrote about it in "Their Water Taps Ran Dry When Meta Built Next Door."

  • According to McKinsey, African American workers would be  disproportionately affected by AI-related job cuts as they occupy the jobs most likely to be replaced first. 

  • Inadequate attention has been given to the health impacts data centers can cause. Wastewater from an Amazon data center in Oregon has been linked to rare cancers and miscarriages. Data centers are contributing to PFAS pollution. Diesel generators can emit up to 600 times the Nitrous Oxide (NoX) than a natural gas power plant does, adversely affecting the local population..​

  • AI, the technology at the heart of data centers, poses a wide range of ethical concerns, including privacy, transparency, accountability, and bias. 

bottom of page